Coin Community Fears
Damage From Repeal Of Sales-Tax Exemptions; Maryland Current
Battleground By Allen Sykora of
Kitco News | 10 February 2012
(Kitco News) - Michigan coin dealer Pat
Heller saw how much it helped business when his state instituted
a law that exempted sales taxes on precious-metals coins…and
he noticed how dealers in neighboring Ohio were hurt when
such an exemption was taken away.
Industry officials say the lack of such
exemptions hurts dealers in those states since many potential
customers might simply buy from elsewhere. Furthermore,
they argue that a sales tax is inappropriate for an investment
product such as gold anyway; after all, there aren’t
sales taxes when buying equities or real estate as an investment.
As a result, the Industry Council for Tangible
Assets—a trade group for the rare coin, precious metals
and tangible assets industry--is urging members to monitor
their state legislators for any attempts to take away exemptions,
as well as to speak on behalf of dealers in the most recent
sales-tax battleground of Maryland. If the state loses its
exemption, others could follow, starting a “domino”
effect, ICTA said in an alert to its members. Plus, ICTA
said, loss of the Maryland exemption could be a threat to
a series of well-attended coin shows held in Baltimore.
Michigan exempted sales taxes on precious-metals
coins in 1999, said Heller, owner of Liberty Coin Service.
“From the time we got our exemption,
our company’s total sales have gone up 10 times,”
Heller said. “But, our in-state retail sales have
increased about 30 times. The business has been good, but
the improvement in Michigan retail sales was highly affected
by the existence of the exemption.”
Heller’s business grew from six to
22 employees.
“There have also been more conventions
in Michigan,” he continued. “Ohio used to have
an exemption. And because of that, many Michigan dealers
would go to coin shows in Ohio to set up and do business.”
When Michigan approved an exemption, its
dealers began staying in-state to set up coin shows. Then
when Ohio lost its exemption, dealers from there began traveling
to Michigan to set up shows, Heller said. This meant the
exemption also benefited Michigan hotels, restaurants and
gas stations.
Further, Heller said, there were estimates
that within six months after Ohio revoked its sales-tax
exemption, at least 100 coin dealerships closed or else
cut back their staff. “It had an immediate and dramatic
effect.”
Industry Told To Be On Lookout For
Threats To Sales-Tax Exemptions
A proposal that would have taxed coin sales
was beaten back last year in Texas and Maryland, before
the issue resurfaced in Maryland, said Diane Piret, director
of industry affairs for ICTA. State governments everywhere
are on the lookout to increase revenue, not just in Maryland,
she said. Lawmakers tend to look at any tax exemptions as
lost revenue and feel that taking these away is less likely
to draw the wrath of voters than would outright tax hikes.
Some states do tax coin sales, although in the majority,
there is either an exemption or no sales taxes at all.
“All states are looking at how they
can raise money,” Piret said. “There are no
states saying they have so much money they don’t know
what to do with it.”
Nevertheless, she and others say damage
would be caused by removal of exemptions, both to coin services
and other businesses, such as less money spent at hotels
and restaurants if states were to lose coin shows and conventions.
Philosophically, many in the industry consider
a tax on an investment product such as gold coins to be
improper to begin with. Imagine putting a sales tax on purchases
of stocks. “That wouldn’t go over very well,
would it,” Piret said.
Further, dealers in states that repeal the
exemption are likely to lose sales. For instance, Maryland’s
sales tax is 6%. So at $1,740 an ounce for gold (around
the time Piret was interviewed Thursday), the sales tax
would be $104. “That’s horrific,” she
said.
ICTA urges the dealing community to monitor
legislatures in individual states and to consider hiring
lobbyists. Often, lobbyists can act as eyes and ears in
the hallways of legislative buildings and help nix proposals
while they are still in the talking stages and before they
formally introduced, Piret pointed out.
“We always have to watch out for these
things,” Piret said. “If you don’t have
somebody watching your legislature, get somebody…They
(exemptions) are hard to get to begin with. To get one back
that they’ve repealed takes years and a lot of money.”
The Maryland situation is especially frustrating
for those in the industry, Piret said, since opponents thought
they had won the fight just last year. At the time, the
group urged members from around the country to call the
Maryland governor’s office and received a large response.
Maryland Becomes Latest Battleground
Over Exemption
Maryland Governor Martin O’Malley
has proposed not only new taxes but a repeal of several
sales-tax exemptions, including gasoline, to balance the
budget. The coin business also would be affected.
This would “dramatically” impact
a series of three major shows held in Baltimore each year
by Whitman Coin & Collectibles Expo, said David Crenshaw,
general manager. The state now has an exemption on sales
of $1,000 or more, he explained. The Whitman expos have
been in Maryland for 40 years and have been held at the
Baltimore Convention Center for two decades. It draws several
thousand attendees who come from many states.
Loss of the exemption would also have an
impact on coin dealers and their employees in the Maryland,
Crenshaw said. His company is encouraging the collecting
community, including dealers in and out of state, to communicate
opposition to the exemption repeal to members of the key
legislative committees. Whitman has dedicated a portion
of its Web site to the issue (http://whitman.com/news/Maryland-Governor-Proposes-Sales-Tax-Exemption-Repeal)
and has enlisted a lobbyist.
Longtime Maryland dealer Julian Leidman,
owner of Bonanza Coins, recounted that the industry won
approval of the exemption back in 1991 to “even the
playing field” so Maryland firms would not lose business
to out-of-state companies. The field would be uneven again
with loss of the exemption, he said.
“It would send the person out of state
to buy something,” said Leidman, who has been in the
business since 1965. “Now, they can already buy it
on the Internet and pay a small shipping charge. But some
people like to do business locally and come in and see who
they are doing business with. That is going to drive these
people away. Adding 6% to the price of a gold coin is kind
of ludicrous. I’m lucky on a large purchase if I make
1%....
“So, how it would affect me is that
it would take all of those people away and reduce my sales
and profit significantly. And, to be honest with you, it
very well might have me close the retail business here.”
Proponents for retaining the sales-tax exemptions
argue that their loss would even have negative ramifications
for state coffers. Lawmakers might find they end up with
less, not more, revenues.
For instance, the Baltimore expos contribute
several million dollars a year to the local economy, Crenshaw
said. The expo generates some 1,000 room nights over a week.
As a result, a loss in attendance would mean less for the
state in lodging taxes and sales taxes on other items such
as restaurant, souvenir and entertainment spending by those
who travel to Baltimore for the expos.
In Michigan, Heller did a study four years
ago on the long-term implications for state coffers following
removal of the sales-tax exemption on precious-metals coins.
He concluded that other forms of taxes—such as income
taxes on a greater number of businesses and employees--more
than offset the loss of sales-tax receipts on coins.
“The exemptions have actually proved
to be a net benefit to the State of Michigan,” Heller
said. “I’m confident that is applicable elsewhere
around the country. I don’t think it makes fiscal
sense to eliminate that particular exemption.”